AniTAY’s Favorite Anime of 2018: Part Two!

Hello AniTAY! I have returned from my sabbatical without wi-fi and am being pressured from all sides to continue revealing the continuation of the Favorite Anime list. So here we go with Part Two, and #24-11 on AniTAY’s compilation!

Just to remind everyone, this was a compilation obtained by yours truly of 23 different contributors to AniTAY’s community of their top 10 anime of last year. #10 on each list got 1 point up to #1 with 10 points. In Part One, we saw a number of shows that appeared on maybe one or two different Top 10’s, but now in Part Two, we’ll begin to see some of the more well-heralded and consensus good shows of 2018. You’ll have to be patient though for the Top 10; that will be revealed in Part Three that will be released sometime early next week. If you missed it though, here’s the link to Part One with the 25th placed show all the way down to #64 with 1 measly point. 

Let’s get to it!

That Time I Got Reincarnated as a Slime!


24th Place: That Time I Got Reincarnated as a Slime! – 13 points

Happy Sugar Life

23rd Place: Happy Sugar Life – 14 points

Killing Bites


22nd Place: Killing Bites – 15 points (1 first place)

Irodoku: The World in Colors

21st Place: Irodoku: The World in Colors – 17 points

Cells at Work


20nd Place: Cells at Work – 20 points (1 first place)

Asobi Asobase: Workshop of Fun

Tied for 18th Place: Asobi Asobase: Workshop of Fun – 21 points
Tied for 18th Place: Jojo’s Bizarre Adventure: Golden Wind – 21 points


Revue Starlight

17th Place: Revue Starlight – 22 points

Zombieland Saga


16th Place: Zombieland Saga – 25 points

Wotakoi: Love is Hard for Otaku

15th Place: Wotakoi: Love is Hard for Otaku – 27 points



14th Place: Aggretsuko – 29 points

After the Rain

13th Place: After the Rain– 31 points (1 first place)

Lupin III Part 5


12th Place: Lupin III: Part 5 – 33 points

Golden Kamuy

11th Place: Golden Kamuy – 36 points

And now only the Top 10 remains! And while Golden Kamuy over here garned a respectable 36 points, our #10 show earned 42 points on its own. But our top 6 shows of 2018 all reached over 70+ points! Who will gain the top spot this year and join the likes of Konosuba/Descending Stories: Showa Genroku Rakugo Shinju (Tied winners for 2016) and Tsukigakirei (Winner of 2017)? You’ll have to be patient. How is the list shaping up for you so far? Let us know in the comments and react with our fellow contributors to our collective good/bad/terrible taste!